Jeff BullasSmart question. You’re right to ask if AI can summarize competitor sites and pull out their positioning — it’s one of the fastest, lowest-risk wins you can get from AI.
Why this matters
- Websites hide positioning in plain sight: hero lines, pricing pages, case studies, and CTAs.
- AI can scan these quickly and standardize insights so you can compare apples to apples.
- Goal: a one-page battlecard per competitor plus a simple map of where you can win.
What you’ll need (15–45 minutes)
- 3–5 competitor URLs (homepage, pricing, features/solutions, and one case study).
- A browser and any AI chat that can read pasted text or browse pages.
- Optional: Reader Mode or “Print to PDF” to get clean text for pasting.
>
Do / Don’t checklist
- Do focus on: homepage hero, subheads, social proof, pricing/plan names, and the first 100 words of each page.
- Do grab About/Company language and any industry logos; these reveal target segments.
- Do standardize your output (same headings each time) so comparisons are clear.
- Do ask AI what’s missing (e.g., no pricing, weak proof, vague ROI).
- Don’t assume AI fetched every dynamic element; paste key text if a page blocks scraping.
- Don’t copy private or gated content; stick to public pages.
- Don’t stop at claims; ask for evidence sources (case studies, numbers) or mark as unsubstantiated.
Insider trick: Ask AI to infer positioning from subtle cues: plan names (Starter/Pro/Enterprise hint segments), hero image alt text, footer microcopy, awards badges, and repeated keywords in headlines. Also use search operators in your browser like: site:competitor.com pricing OR plans, site:competitor.com case study OR “customer story”.
Step-by-step: from URL to positioning map
- Collect 3–5 key URLs per competitor: Home, Pricing, Features/Solutions, About, and one Case Study.
- Capture text: Use Reader Mode or copy sections into your AI chat. If the tool can browse, give it the URLs and ask it to quote key snippets it’s using.
- Standardize extraction: Run the prompt below for each competitor.
- Compare: Feed all outputs to AI and ask for overlaps, gaps, and 2–3 “white space” angles you could own.
- Draft your angle: Use the final prompt to create your own positioning and homepage hero ideas.
Copy-paste prompt (single competitor)
Analyze the website content below and extract their market positioning. Deliver a concise report in this exact outline and keep each bullet to one line:
1) Category and sub-category they want to own
2) Primary target segments (job titles, industries, company sizes)
3) Core pain points they focus on (3–5)
4) Value proposition and proof (claims + evidence cited)
5) Key features emphasized (not every feature; only proof-carrying ones)
6) Pricing and packaging signals (plan names, value levers)
7) Tone of voice and brand personality (2–3 adjectives)
8) Primary CTAs and offers
9) SEO/keyword hints from headings (5–8)
10) Positioning statement (fill this: “For [target] who [need], [brand] is a [category] that [unique benefit]. Unlike [alternatives], it [differentiator].”)
11) What they are not saying (notable omissions that could be weak spots)
Return the output as labeled bullets only. Here is the content: [paste homepage hero + pricing + features + about + one case study]
Copy-paste prompt (compare 3–5 competitors)
You are a market analyst. Using the competitor reports above, do three things:
A) Common ground: list the 5–7 claims everyone makes.
B) White space: list 3–5 defendable angles no one (or only one) emphasizes; note buyer value and proof needed.
C) Risk check: where are competitors strongest (proof-rich), and where are they bluffing (claims without evidence)? Keep it tight and actionable.
Copy-paste prompt (draft your positioning)
Based on the white space opportunities identified, write 3 alternative positioning routes. For each route include: 1) Positioning statement, 2) 12-word homepage hero line, 3) Subhead that names the buyer and outcome, 4) 3 proof points I could realistically gather within 60 days, 5) One CTA that reduces risk (trial, audit, template). Keep the language plain and specific.
Worked example (fictitious)
- Competitor A (AcmeCRM)
- Category: SMB sales CRM with AI forecasting
- Targets: Sales managers in SaaS, 10–200 seats
- Pains: Pipeline visibility, rep adoption, forecast accuracy
- Value + proof: “+22% forecast accuracy”; 3 logo case studies
- Features: Deal stages, AI scoring, Gmail plugin
- Pricing: Free, Pro, Enterprise; AI add-on
- Tone: Confident, numbers-led; CTA: “Start free”
- Omissions: Weak implementation story
- Competitor B (BrightSales)
- Category: RevOps platform
- Targets: RevOps leaders, mid-market
- Pains: Data silos, reporting
- Value + proof: “Single source of truth”; vague proof
- Pricing: Contact sales only
- Tone: Enterprise, jargon-heavy; CTA: “Book demo”
- Omissions: No transparent pricing
- Competitor C (CareTrack)
- Category: Healthcare CRM niche
- Targets: Clinics; HIPAA first
- Pains: Compliance, patient follow-up
- Value + proof: HIPAA badges; 2 healthcare case studies
- Pricing: Tiered by locations
- Tone: Trust and safety; CTA: “See compliance checklist”
- Omissions: Limited AI story
Comparison insight
- Overlap: Everyone claims “visibility” and “centralized data.”
- White space: Fast time-to-value with a 14-day guided setup and guaranteed adoption metric; transparent pricing calculator; compliance + AI story for regulated SMBs.
- Risk: AcmeCRM has evidence on accuracy; BrightSales is light on proof; CareTrack owns compliance.
Common mistakes & quick fixes
- Messy inputs: If AI output feels vague, you likely gave vague inputs. Fix: paste the exact hero, pricing table labels, and one case study quote.
- Over-long reports: Cap each bullet to one line. Ask for a 200–300 word limit.
- Tool blind spots: Some pages block bots. Fix: copy snippets manually or use Reader Mode.
- Shiny object bias: Features ≠ positioning. Always tie features to a buyer outcome and proof.
Action plan (today)
- List 3 competitors and collect 4–5 URLs each.
- Run the single-competitor prompt for all three; save results.
- Run the comparison prompt to spot overlaps and white space.
- Use the drafting prompt to create 3 positioning routes. Pick one to test.
- Update your homepage hero and CTA with the chosen route; add or plan proof points.
Expectation setting
- In 30–45 minutes you’ll have standardized snapshots and 2–3 differentiated angles.
- These are hypotheses. Validate fast: a headline A/B test, a pricing page tweak, or a short customer interview.
Closing thought: AI won’t decide your strategy, but it will compress the research time from days to an hour and surface patterns you can act on now.