"Join over 25 million other readers that have been educated and inspired to transform their life and business"

Start Your Online Side Hustle. Click Here

How to Choose the Right SEO Agency For Your Business

seo agency

In an era where digital presence defines business success, Search Engine Optimization (SEO) has become more than just a marketing buzzword. 

Try these new AI-powered tools:

  • Surfer helps you research, write, and optimize your content in less than an hour.
  • SEO.ai generates content and articles fast. The service operates in 50 languages.
  • SimpleTraffic can drive real visitors to your website. Try 5 days for free and cancel anytime!

The right SEO strategy can significantly improve your website’s visibility, drive traffic, and enhance user engagement. 

However, the ever-evolving nature of SEO makes it a challenging domain. This is where an SEO agency comes into play. 

Choosing the right SEO agency is crucial for your business, and here’s how you can make an informed decision.

What does an SEO agency do?

An SEO agency is a specialized company that helps improve the online presence of your business. They focus on optimizing your website to rank higher in search engine results pages (SERPs), which in turn can lead to increased organic traffic. 

Typical services include keyword research, content creation, on-page optimization, link building, and technical SEO. 

These agencies bring expertise and tools that most businesses do not have in-house, ensuring a more effective SEO strategy.

When to hire an SEO agency

Deciding when to hire an SEO agency is a pivotal decision for any business aiming to strengthen its online presence.

There are several key moments when the need for professional SEO services becomes particularly apparent:

  • Launching a New Website: When you’re launching a new website, it’s crucial to get your SEO right from the start. An SEO agency can ensure that your site is optimized for search engines from day one, helping to establish a strong foundation for future growth. This includes keyword research tailored to your target audience, optimizing site structure for search engine crawling, and ensuring that all content is SEO-friendly.
  • Rebranding Your Business: Rebranding involves more than just changing your logo or company name. It’s about re-establishing your business’s identity in the market. During a rebrand, an SEO agency can help ensure that your new brand is visible and appealing to both search engines and your target audience. They can assist in updating SEO strategies to reflect your new brand, target new keywords relevant to the rebrand, and manage the transition without losing your existing search engine rankings.
  • Underperforming SEO Efforts: If you notice that your current SEO strategies are not yielding the expected results, it might be time to seek professional help. This could manifest as stagnant or declining website traffic, poor rankings for your key terms, or a lack of growth in leads or sales attributed to organic search. An SEO agency can perform a comprehensive audit of your existing efforts, identify areas of improvement, and implement strategies that align more closely with your business goals.

Professional SEO services offer more than just immediate improvements in rankings or traffic. They are an investment in the long-term growth and sustainability of your business. 

By keeping abreast of the latest SEO trends and algorithm updates, agencies can help you continuously adapt and refine your strategy, ensuring that your business remains competitive. 

Additionally, by leveraging their expertise and resources, you can often achieve more efficient and effective results than with in-house efforts alone.

In-house SEO vs. outsourcing

The decision between building an in-house SEO team or outsourcing to an agency depends on several factors, including budget, scale of operations, and available resources.

While an in-house team offers more direct control and alignment with internal objectives, it can be expensive and limited in expertise.

Outsourcing, on the other hand, provides access to a diverse range of skills and experiences but requires trust and relinquishing some degree of control.

Types of SEO agencies

Local SEO Agency

A Local SEO Agency is ideal for businesses that primarily serve a local customer base, such as restaurants, local retailers, or service providers. These agencies specialize in optimizing your online presence to appear in local search queries and on platforms like Google Maps. 

Key services include optimizing your Google My Business listing, local citations, and location-based keywords. 

They help ensure that when potential customers in your area search for services or products you offer, your business appears prominently in local search results, thereby driving foot traffic and local sales.

Ecommerce SEO Agency

Ecommerce SEO Agencies specialize in optimizing online stores to enhance visibility and increase sales conversions. They understand the unique challenges of ranking in competitive online retail spaces and are adept at crafting strategies tailored to various e-commerce platforms. 

Their services typically include optimizing product descriptions, improving website structure for better user experience, enhancing mobile responsiveness, and implementing effective keyword strategies. 

These agencies aim to improve your product visibility in search engine results, leading to increased traffic and higher conversion rates for your online store.

B2B SEO Agency

B2B SEO Agencies focus on developing strategies for businesses whose primary customers are other businesses. Unlike B2C, B2B SEO often involves longer sales cycles and a need for lead generation and nurturing. 

These agencies specialize in creating content that appeals to decision-makers within businesses, focusing on industry-specific keywords, and establishing authority and trustworthiness in a specific field. 

They work on optimizing your website and content to generate high-quality leads and improve conversion rates, often through targeted content marketing, strategic keyword targeting, and enhancing your site’s user experience for a professional audience.

Shopify SEO Agency

Shopify SEO Agencies offer specialized expertise in optimizing Shopify-based e-commerce websites. Shopify, being one of the most popular e-commerce platforms, has specific SEO opportunities and challenges. 

These agencies are skilled in leveraging Shopify’s built-in SEO-friendly features while addressing its limitations. 

Their services include optimizing your Shopify store’s structure, improving product pages, enhancing loading speed, and ensuring mobile responsiveness. They aim to drive organic traffic specifically to your Shopify store, thereby increasing sales and customer engagement.

SaaS SEO Agency

SaaS (Software as a Service) SEO Agencies provide tailored strategies for SaaS companies, which often operate in highly competitive online spaces. They focus on identifying and targeting competitive keywords relevant to the SaaS industry and addressing the specific challenges of marketing software products. 

Their services include creating in-depth content that showcases the value of the software, optimizing for keywords that attract potential subscribers, and building a strong online authority to stand out in a crowded market. 

They aim to increase your SaaS product’s visibility, drive sign-ups, and reduce churn by attracting and retaining the right audience.

Each of these agencies brings specialized knowledge and strategies tailored to specific business models and industries. By understanding these nuances, businesses can better choose an SEO agency that aligns with their unique goals and target audience.

What to look for when hiring an agency

Key factors in selecting an SEO agency include their track record, expertise, and alignment with your business needs. 

Look for agencies with a proven portfolio, positive client testimonials, and transparent communication practices. 

The right agency should not only understand SEO but also your unique business challenges and objectives.

How to work with an SEO agency

Working effectively with an SEO agency requires understanding their processes, tools, and the benchmarks for measuring progress. Here are key aspects to consider:


  • Initial Assessment and Strategy Development: The agency will start by conducting an in-depth analysis of your current website and SEO performance. This includes reviewing your website structure, content, keyword rankings, and competitor analysis. Based on this, they will develop a tailored SEO strategy that aligns with your business objectives.
  • Implementation Phase: This involves the execution of the SEO strategy. It can include on-site optimization (like content creation and website modifications) and off-site tactics (like link building and social media strategies).
  • Regular Reporting and Meetings: Expect regular updates and meetings to review progress. These sessions are opportunities to discuss the results, adjust strategies, and ensure alignment with business goals.


  • SEO and Analytics Tools: Agencies use a variety of tools for keyword research (like SEMrush or Ahrefs), on-site analysis (such as Moz or Screaming Frog), and analytics (like Google Analytics). Familiarize yourself with these tools as they provide valuable insights into your SEO performance.
  • Communication Platforms: Agencies often use project management and communication tools (such as Slack, Asana, or Trello) to keep you updated on the project’s progress and facilitate ongoing communication.

What to Expect

  • Timeline for Results: SEO is a long-term strategy. It’s important to have realistic expectations regarding timelines. Significant improvements can take several months.
  • SEO Best Practices: Expect the agency to adhere to ethical SEO practices. Avoid agencies that promise immediate results, as these may involve questionable tactics that can hurt your ranking in the long run.

Measuring Progress

  • Rankings: Monitor changes in your website’s ranking for targeted keywords.
  • Traffic: Look at the organic traffic data in Google Analytics to see how many visitors are coming to your site through search engines.
  • Conversions: Track how many of these visitors are converting into leads or sales.
  • ROI: Ultimately, measure the return on investment by comparing the revenue generated from organic traffic against the cost of the SEO services.

When to Fire Them

  • Lack of Results: If there are no improvements in rankings, traffic, or conversions over a significant period, despite their efforts, it might be time to reconsider the partnership.
  • Poor Communication: Consistent lack of transparency, missed reports, or failure to communicate effectively are red flags.
  • Unethical Practices: If the agency employs black-hat SEO tactics, it’s not only ineffective but can also penalize your website.

Final thoughts 

Selecting the right SEO agency is a vital decision for your business’s online success.

By understanding what to look for and how to effectively work with an agency, you can ensure that your SEO strategy is in capable hands, driving growth and improving your online presence.


What does an SEO agency do?

An SEO agency optimizes your website to improve its visibility in search engine results pages (SERPs). 

This involves a variety of tasks, including keyword research, content creation and optimization, technical SEO (improving site structure, mobile-friendliness, loading speeds), link building, and often, ongoing analysis and adjustments based on search engine algorithm updates.

How much do SEO agencies charge?

The cost of hiring an SEO agency can vary widely depending on factors like the agency’s expertise, project scope, and your specific business needs. 

Generally, prices can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars per month. Some agencies might offer package deals, while others charge hourly rates or retainer fees.

Are SEO agencies worth it?

Hiring an SEO agency can be worth it if you lack the time, resources, or expertise to handle SEO in-house. 

They bring specialized knowledge and tools that can significantly improve your website’s search engine ranking and visibility, potentially leading to increased traffic and sales.

What is the SEO agency process?

Typically, an SEO agency’s process includes an initial website audit and competitive analysis, strategy development, implementation of SEO tactics (such as on-page optimization and link building), regular monitoring and reporting of results, and ongoing strategy adjustments based on analytics and search engine algorithm changes.

What are the top reasons to hire an SEO agency?

Key reasons include their expertise in SEO, ability to stay up-to-date with the latest trends and algorithm changes, access to specialized tools and resources, and the potential to achieve better results than in-house efforts, especially if you lack dedicated SEO staff.

Can I hire someone to do my SEO?

Yes, you can hire an individual, such as a freelancer or a dedicated in-house SEO specialist, to manage your SEO. This can be a good option if you prefer a more hands-on approach or have specific SEO needs that one person can effectively manage.

What services do SEO agencies offer?

SEO agencies typically offer services such as keyword research and strategy, on-page optimization (content development, meta tags, usability improvements), off-page optimization (link building, social media strategies), technical SEO (site architecture, mobile optimization, page speed), and continuous performance analysis and reporting.

How much does it cost to start SEO?

The initial cost of starting SEO can vary. If you do it yourself, costs might be minimal, primarily your time and effort. If you hire an agency or a consultant, the setup cost can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on the complexity of your website and your specific goals.

How do I set up my own SEO?

To set up your own SEO, start with a website audit to identify areas for improvement. Research keywords relevant to your business, optimize your website content and structure for these keywords, ensure your website is mobile-friendly and loads quickly, build quality backlinks, and regularly create quality, relevant content. Also, monitor your website’s performance using tools like Google Analytics and Google Search Console.

How to get 100% SEO?

Achieving “100% SEO” is a bit of a misnomer, as SEO is an ongoing process rather than a one-time goal. It involves continuous optimization and adaptation to changing search algorithms and market trends. Focus on consistently applying best practices in on-page and off-page SEO, staying updated with the latest SEO trends, and regularly analyzing and refining your strategies based on performance metrics.

organic traffic guide

Free Download

The Ultimate Guide to Organic Traffic for Small Business


You May Also Like