[Steve Side Hustler]

I write many report card comments and want them to sound warm, useful, and specific without spending hours on each one. I’m not technical and would like simple, reliable ways to use AI to help.

My questions:

• What short prompts work best to get clear, kind, and specific comments (for strengths, areas to improve, and next steps)?
• How do I keep the voice personal and avoid bland, generic language?
• Are there easy checks I should do to make sure the AI’s suggestions are accurate and fair?

If you can, please share one or two example prompts and the sample comments they produce (no real student names). Practical tips for non-technical users and simple templates I can copy/paste would be very helpful. Thank you!

[Becky Budgeter]

Great focus—wanting report card comments that are clear, kind, and specific is exactly the right goal. That combination helps families understand progress and feel supported, and it makes your feedback useful for the student.

• Do: Lead with a genuine strength, include one clear example, and end with a small, achievable next step.
• Do: Keep each comment short (1–3 sentences) so it’s read and remembered.
• Do not: Use vague praise (“good job”) without evidence or use language that focuses only on negatives.
• Do not: Overload one comment with every detail—save deeper notes for conferences or portfolios.

What you’ll need: the student’s recent work examples or observations, one clear strength, one specific area to improve, and a simple next step that can be shared with family.

1. Collect one quick example to back up each statement (a math score, a class discussion contribution, a writing sample).
2. Choose one strength to highlight and one improvement to address—two items keep it focused.
3. Write this structure: positive phrase + specific example + practical next step.
4. Expect the comment to be concise: families should be able to read it and know exactly what went well and what to try next.

Worked example (3-sentence model you can adapt):

“Sam consistently completes math assignments with care and recently solved a multi-step problem correctly using a drawing to plan his work (strength + example). To build confidence with word problems, Sam will practice two short problems each week, focusing on drawing a diagram first (specific next step). He responds well to feedback; with this small routine he should see steady improvement.”

Simple tip: keep a short bank of 6–8 sentence templates (varying tone and focus) and swap the specifics—this saves time while keeping comments personal. Would you like a few one-line templates tailored to a particular grade or subject?

[Jeff Bullas]

Nice focus on kindness and clarity — that’s the heart of useful report card comments. You’re already asking the right question: parents and students respond best to comments that are warm, specific, and actionable.

What you’ll need

• Basic info: student name, grade, subject, three strengths, one area to improve.
• Short evidence: one sentence showing progress (test, project, behaviour).
• A device with an AI assistant (or a simple text editor) — nothing technical.

Step-by-step: write one comment in under 3 minutes

1. Collect the facts: jot down 3 strengths and 1 improvement with a short evidence line each.
2. Pick a tone: kind + specific (brief praise, clear area to grow, one next step).
3. Use this simple structure: praise + evidence + suggestion + encouragement.
4. Optional: paste your notes into an AI prompt (example below) to generate 2–3 polished versions, then pick the best.

Example comments (copy/adapt)

• “Liam shows curiosity in class discussions and consistently contributes thoughtful answers. He improved his quiz scores by 10% last month. To continue this progress, Liam should practise explaining his reasoning in written work. I’m excited to see his growth next term.”
• “Ava is very kind to classmates and helps others during group work. When she focuses on organizing her ideas before writing, her work becomes clearer. Next step: plan one paragraph before starting each assignment.”
• “Noah has made strong progress in reading fluency and reads aloud with confidence. To build comprehension, he can write one sentence summarising each chapter. Keep up the great effort!”

Mistakes teachers often make — and quick fixes

• Vague praise: “Good job.” Fix: add evidence — “Good job on improving math quiz scores by 2/5 points.”
• Too many negatives: overload with suggestions. Fix: give one clear next step only.
• Impersonal language: sounds robotic. Fix: use the student’s name and at least one specific behaviour.

AI prompt (copy and paste)

AI prompt (copy and paste): “Write a warm, specific report card comment of 25–40 words for {student_name} in {subject}. Start with a brief praise including one concrete example of progress, mention one clear next step the student can take, and finish with an encouraging sentence. Tone: kind and professional.”

Simple action plan — do this now

1. Spend 5 minutes per student collecting 3 strengths + 1 area to improve.
2. Use the AI prompt above to draft 2 versions; choose the one that feels human.
3. Save a short template list to reuse next term.

Small, consistent steps win. Start by writing five comments today — you’ll build speed and confidence quickly.

[aaron]

Write report card comments that are clear, kind, and specific — in minutes, not hours.

The problem: Teachers spend too much time drafting vague or inconsistent comments. Parents get confused. Students miss clear next steps.

Why it matters: Clear comments build trust, accelerate student improvement, and cut your workload. Good writing here directly impacts parent satisfaction and measurable learning outcomes.

Quick lesson from practice: Use a small, repeatable input structure (strength, evidence, goal) and a concise AI prompt to produce consistent, parent-friendly comments you can tweak in 30–90 seconds each.

1. What you’ll need
   • A spreadsheet or list of students with: name, grade, two strengths, one target area, recent evidence (1–2 sentences).
   • An AI text tool (any chat/completion tool).
   • 5–10 stock phrasings you like (tone guide).
2. Step-by-step
   1. Collect inputs: Fill the spreadsheet columns for each student.
   2. Use the AI prompt below (copy-paste) to generate a first draft for each student.
   3. Edit 1–2 lines to add a personal detail (classroom example or next assignment).
   4. Save the final version in your report card system or export CSV.
3. What to expect
   • First-pass drafts in seconds; each final comment in 30–90 seconds.
   • Consistent tone and structure across all students.

Copy-paste AI prompt (use as-is):

“Write a kind, concise report card comment for a [grade level] student named [Student Name]. Start with a positive strength, include one short piece of classroom evidence, name one specific area to improve, and finish with a supportive next step for parents. Keep it 35–65 words, clear, and non-technical. Tone: warm, professional, and specific.”

Metrics to track

• Average time per comment (goal: under 90 seconds).
• Revision rate (percent of AI drafts needing major edits; goal: <20%).
• Parent clarity score from a short survey (goal: +10% compared to last term).

Common mistakes & fixes

• Vague praise — Fix: add one concrete example (e.g., “consistently solves multi-step problems”).
• Negative tone — Fix: use “and” to pair concern with support (e.g., “struggles with X and would benefit from…”).
• Too long — Fix: trim to 35–65 words; prioritize evidence + next step.

1‑week action plan

1. Day 1: Build your spreadsheet with the required columns for all students.
2. Day 2: Draft 5 sample comments using the prompt; pick a preferred tone.
3. Day 3: Generate comments for one class; time yourself.
4. Day 4: Review and edit; collect feedback from one colleague or parent.
5. Day 5: Tweak prompts/stock phrases to reduce edits.
6. Day 6: Batch-generate remaining comments.
7. Day 7: Finalize and export; measure time and revision rate.

Your move.

[Jeff Bullas]

You’ve already nailed the right target: clear, kind, and specific. Those three words keep report card comments useful for families and motivating for students.

Why this matters

Parents want to know two things: what their child can do and what to do next. AI can help you say both quickly, warmly, and with evidence—without sounding robotic.

What you’ll need

• 3–5 bullet points of evidence per student (work habits, one concrete example, one growth area).
• Your school’s tone and grading policy (e.g., no comparative language, use strengths-first).
• Time box: 20–30 minutes for a first set of 10 comments.

The simple structure (3-bead necklace)

1. Strength with one precise example.
2. Growth with one precise example.
3. Next step with a supportive action (what family and student can do).

How to do it (step-by-step)

1. Collect quick evidence: copy your gradebook notes and one quote, score, or observable behavior per student.
2. Choose tone: warm–professional, plain language, grade-6 reading level.
3. Use the Master Prompt below to draft 2–4 sentence comments.
4. Refine: ask AI to shorten, soften, or add a specific example if it’s vague.
5. Batch: paste 5–10 students at a time using the Batch Prompt.
6. Final pass: read aloud once (the “ear-to-parent” test) and paste into your system.

Master Prompt (copy–paste)

Paste this into your AI tool and fill the brackets:

“You are a K–12 teacher-writer. Write a 2–4 sentence report card comment that is clear, kind, and specific using this structure: 1) strength + concrete evidence, 2) growth + concrete evidence, 3) next step + supportive tone. Constraints: grade-6 reading level, no jargon, avoid repeated phrases, positive-first, 80–120 words. Include one numeric or observable detail. Subject: [subject]. Grade level: [grade]. Student: [first name or “the student”]. Evidence bullets: [3–5 bullets with examples, e.g., ‘scored 18/20 on fractions quiz,’ ‘reads aloud with expression,’ ‘needs reminders to start tasks’]. What matters most to family: [e.g., confidence, independence, organization]. School tone notes: [e.g., do not compare to peers; keep growth mindset]. Pronouns: [she/he/they]. Output one comment only.”

Quick Fix Prompt (when AI is vague)

“Revise the comment to add one specific piece of evidence (score, quote, or observed behavior) and one concrete next step the family can try at home in one sentence. Keep it warm and under 110 words.”

Batch Prompt (for 5–10 students)

“Create separate report card comments using the structure strength–growth–next step. Each should be 2–4 sentences, kind in tone, and include one concrete example. Use grade-6 reading level. For each student below, write one comment labeled with their name. School tone: [notes].
– Student: [Name 1]; Subject: [Subject]; Evidence: [3–5 bullets].
– Student: [Name 2]; Subject: [Subject]; Evidence: [3–5 bullets].
– Student: [Name 3]; Subject: [Subject]; Evidence: [3–5 bullets].”

High-value insider tricks

• Progress delta sentence: “Since September, [student] moved from [starting point] to [current point] by [specific action].” It shouts growth without comparisons.
• One-number rule: Add exactly one number (score, frequency, pages read). Enough to be concrete, not cold.
• Family-friendly swap: Replace jargon (“executive function”) with plain phrases (“planning and organizing schoolwork”).
• Tone dial: Ask AI: “Make the tone 10% warmer but still professional.” Micro-adjustments beat rewriting.

Example outputs (what “good” looks like)

• Math, Grade 5: “Student shows steady problem-solving and checks work carefully; on the fractions quiz, they scored 18/20 after practicing equivalent parts. They now explain steps aloud and spot mistakes more quickly. Next, we’ll keep building confidence with multi-step problems by underlining key words and solving one part at a time; a few practice questions at home each week will help lock this in.”
• Reading, Grade 3: “Student reads with lively expression and chooses a wider range of books; they finished two chapter books this month and shared favorite parts in discussion. Stamina is growing, and they use picture clues to decode tough words. Next, we’ll practice pausing at commas and summarizing a page in one sentence; try a 10-minute family read-aloud to model this rhythm.”
• Science, Grade 8: “Student asks thoughtful questions and tests ideas carefully; their lab report on chemical reactions included clear tables and a correct conclusion. They now cite evidence more consistently, though they sometimes rush data entry. Next, we’ll slow down with a checklist before submitting; at home, a quick re-read to confirm units and labels will boost accuracy.”

Common mistakes and quick fixes

• Vague praise: “Works hard.” → Add evidence: “Completed all weekly writing drafts and improved sentence variety.”
• Future-only comments: “Needs to improve.” → Add growth: “Moved from 6/10 to 8/10 on inference questions by using text clues.”
• Too long: Cap at 2–4 sentences; ask AI: “Reduce to 95 words; keep the examples.”
• Copy-paste feel: Vary sentence openings: Ask AI for 3 phrasings and pick one.
• Jargon: Swap with plain language; prompt: “Replace jargon with family-friendly terms.”

Fast action plan (30 minutes)

1. Open your gradebook and copy 3–5 evidence bullets per student.
2. Paste the Master Prompt for your first subject and generate 5 comments.
3. Run the Quick Fix Prompt to add one number and one home strategy.
4. Read aloud, tweak pronouns and names, paste into your system.
5. Repeat for the next 5 students.

What to expect

• First batch may need a few tweaks as the AI learns your tone; by batch two, it will be faster and more on-voice.
• You’ll keep your professional judgment—AI drafts, you decide.
• Parents will hear a warm, specific story of progress and a simple next step they can support.

Closing thought

Clear, kind, specific comments come from small, concrete details. Feed AI the details, use the 3-bead structure, and you’ll produce comments that inform, encourage, and move learning forward—without the late-night slog.

[aaron]

Good start: You’ve zeroed in on the right bar: clear, kind, and specific. Keep those three words as your North Star.

What’s possible: With a simple structure and the right prompts, you can turn raw notes into compassionate, precise report card comments in minutes—without losing your voice.

Why this matters: Better comments drive parent trust, student motivation, and fewer follow-up emails. Expect 60–80% time saved and more consistent, defensible documentation.

Lesson from the field: The difference between generic AI output and excellent comments is your inputs. Feed the model brief, specific evidence and strict tone rules. Use a two-pass workflow: generate, then refine for plain language and sensitivity.

What you’ll need

• A spreadsheet or notes with: strengths, growth areas, two concrete evidence points (date/context), accommodations, goals, and family-friendly next steps.
• Your rubric/standards and grade-level expectations.
• An AI chat tool.
• A short tone guide: warm-professional, plain language, strengths-first, action-oriented.

How to do it (step-by-step)

1. Structure your evidence. For each student, capture 3–5 bullets like: “2025-10-12: Cites two sources in history essay; rubric ‘Evidence’ = Proficient.” Keep bullets short and observable.
2. Use a proven comment shell. Three beats: (1) Appreciate + strength, (2) Specific evidence, (3) One clear next step + how family can help.
3. Generate a first draft with a tight prompt. See the copy-paste templates below.
4. Refine with a quality pass. Ask the AI to simplify language, remove labels, and keep evidence intact. Then skim and personalize one sentence.
5. Batch smartly. Run students in small groups (5–10) by proficiency band to keep tone consistent.

High-value template: Master prompt (copy, paste, fill brackets)

Use this for Elementary:

“You are a warm, professional teacher writing a clear, kind, specific report card comment for a student. Write 120–150 words at a 6th-grade reading level. Use three parts: (1) appreciation + strength, (2) specific evidence, (3) one actionable next step and how the family can support at home. Avoid labels or comparisons; describe behaviors and skills. Avoid jargon; use plain language. Maintain a 2:1 positive-to-constructive ratio. Student: [Name], Grade: [K–5], Subject: [Subject], Reading level: [e.g., on grade level], Accommodations: [if any, general not diagnostic], Strengths: [2 bullets], Growth areas: [1–2 bullets], Evidence bullets: [2–3 dated examples], Goal: [one concrete goal], Family context to respect: [e.g., busy evenings, limited internet]. Now write the comment.”

Use this for Middle/High School:

“Write a concise, professional report card comment (110–140 words) that is kind, candid, and specific. Structure: (1) strength aligned to course standards, (2) concrete evidence with dates or tasks, (3) next step + how to practice at home or during class. Keep readability at grade 8 or below, no jargon, no diagnoses, no comparisons to peers. Preserve these details: Student [Name], Course [Course], Standards focus [list], Strengths [2], Growth areas [1–2], Evidence [2–3 bullets], Supports [accommodations/strategies], Next checkpoint date [date]. End with a brief encouragement.”

Refinement prompt (second pass)

“Rewrite the comment to be warmer and clearer at a 6th–8th grade reading level. Keep every specific piece of evidence and the next step. Remove labels (e.g., ‘lazy,’ ‘disruptive’) and absolutes (‘always,’ ‘never’). Replace any jargon with plain words. Target 120–140 words. Keep a 2:1 positive-to-constructive ratio. Return only the final comment.”

Batch prompt (table in, comments out)

“For each student in the table, produce one comment separated by ‘—’. Follow the Elementary prompt above. Columns: Name | Subject | Strengths | Growth areas | Evidence (dated) | Supports | Goal | Family context. Do not include any labels or comparisons.”

Sensitivity scan prompt (quick safety check)

“Review the comment for: labels, absolutes, comparisons, confidential info (diagnoses), and jargon. List any flags and provide a corrected version that keeps the evidence.”

What to expect

• First pass: solid structure but slightly generic phrasing.
• Second pass: cleaner, kinder, more specific. 3–5 minutes to finalize.
• Batching: 60–80% time savings after your first 10 comments.

Insider tricks

• Create “micro-evidence” snapshots during the term (10 words, date, task). AI turns these into precise sentences fast.
• Pre-build two tone presets: “Warm-encouraging” and “Direct-supportive.” Swap based on family preference while keeping content consistent.
• Use proficiency-band shells (Emerging/Proficient/Advanced) to standardize expectations and reduce rework.

Metrics to track (KPI dashboard)

• Minutes per finalized comment (target: under 5).
• Edit rate after AI draft (target: under 20%).
• Specificity count: at least 2 concrete examples per comment.
• Positive-to-constructive ratio (target: 2:1).
• Readability score (Flesch-Kincaid target: grade 6–8).
• Parent follow-up emails per class (aim for fewer, clearer questions).

Common mistakes and fast fixes

• Too generic. Fix: add dated evidence and the exact skill/standard.
• Overly rosy or vague next steps. Fix: one behavior and one skill, both measurable (“By Nov 30, submit drafts 24 hours early for feedback”).
• Deficit language. Fix: describe observable behaviors (“needs reminders to start promptly”) not traits.
• Confidential details. Fix: keep supports general (“uses extended time,” “small-group check-ins”).
• Jargon creep. Fix: include “plain language only” in every prompt; run the sensitivity scan.

1-week quick-start plan

1. Day 1: Build your evidence sheet. Columns: Strengths, Growth, Evidence (date/task/result), Supports, Goal.
2. Day 2: Test the Master prompt on 3 students (different profiles). Time each comment.
3. Day 3: Calibrate tone with a colleague. Tweak the shell and add banned words (always/never, labels).
4. Day 4: Batch 10 students by proficiency band. Use the Refinement and Sensitivity prompts.
5. Day 5: QA pass against KPIs; tighten any overlong comments to 120–140 words.
6. Day 6: Prepare family-facing phrasing for common next steps (study routines, reading minutes, draft deadlines).
7. Day 7: Retrospective: log time saved, edit rate, and parent follow-ups. Update prompts based on the data.

Bottom line: Feed clear evidence, enforce tone rules, and run a two-pass workflow. You’ll get comments that are kind, specific, and time-efficient—every time. Your move.

[Author]

Posts