[Becky Budgeter]

Hello — I’m not a designer or a tech expert, but I want to use AI to create a logo that looks great as a small app icon. I’m hoping for practical, step-by-step advice I can follow.

What I’m most interested in:

• Tools: Which types of AI tools or workflows work best for logo concepts (and for turning them into crisp icons)?
• Prompts & process: How do I write prompts or guide an AI so the result is simple, legible, and recognizable at 48–180 px?
• Formats & export: What file types and sizes should I export (vector vs raster)?
• Design tips: Key rules for color, contrast, and detail reduction for small sizes.

If you’ve done this before, could you share a short example prompt, a recommended simple workflow, or common pitfalls to avoid? Links to beginner-friendly guides or sample before/after icons are welcome. Thanks — I appreciate clear, non-technical steps I can try tonight.

[Steve Side Hustler]

Nice thread — you already hit a useful point: app icons are a different animal than full logos. They need a bold, simple silhouette and colors that read at thumb-size. Here’s a quick win you can try in under 5 minutes and a short workflow for turning AI ideas into app-ready icons.

Quick 5-minute test: Pick the single symbol that represents your app (a cloud, a leaf, a lightning bolt). Ask an AI tool to make three square variations emphasizing a strong silhouette and two high-contrast colors. Download them and view at 48×48 pixels — if the shape still reads, you’re on the right track.

What you’ll need

• A short description of the core idea (one sentence).
• An AI image or logo tool (any simple generator or logo maker).
• Basic image editor (can be free; enough to crop, resize, export PNG/SVG).
• A phone or browser window to preview tiny sizes.

Step-by-step: how to do it

1. Clarify the core symbol and emotion (e.g., “fast + friendly = lightning + rounded corners”).
2. Generate 3 square concepts that focus on a single bold shape and max two colors — avoid small text or thin strokes.
3. Open each result and crop to a square; check it at 48×48 and 72×72. If it blurs into a blob, simplify the shape and remake.
4. Pick the best silhouette and create a version in greyscale to ensure contrast holds without color.
5. Refine: add 10–20% safe margin around the symbol, test with rounded corners, and export a high-res master (1024×1024) plus common sizes (512, 180, 120, 48 px).
6. Save both a vector (SVG) and layered master if possible so you can tweak later.

What to expect

• First drafts will often be too detailed — expect 2–3 quick iterations to simplify.
• Icons typically work best with 1–2 colors, a distinct silhouette, and no small type.
• Exporting a clean SVG or a crisp 1024 PNG gives you options for store listings and marketing.

Mini habit: whenever you have a new feature idea, spend 10 minutes repeating this loop—generate, test at small size, simplify, export. Over a few sessions you’ll end up with a handful of strong icon choices and a repeatable process that doesn’t eat your time.

[Jeff Bullas]

Quick win (under 5 minutes): Pick one simple symbol that sums up your app (cloud, leaf, lightning). Ask an AI to generate three square icons that use one bold shape and two high-contrast colors. Download and view them at 48×48 — if the shape still reads, you’ve already got something useful.

Context: app icons are tiny billboards. They must read at thumb-size, work on different backgrounds, and still look good when used as a store tile or a shortcut on a phone. AI speeds up idea exploration, but you still need to simplify and test.

What you’ll need

• A one-sentence description of your app’s core idea or feeling.
• An AI image or logo generator (any simple tool will do).
• A basic image editor that can crop, resize and export PNG/SVG.
• A phone or browser to preview the icon at small sizes.

Step-by-step (do this now)

1. Write a one-line brief: symbol + mood (example: “task app — fast & friendly = lightning + rounded corners”).
2. Use the AI prompt below to generate 3 square options. Ask for transparent background and 1–2 colors.
3. Open each result, crop to a square, then preview at 1024, 512, 180, 120 and 48 px. Keep the simplest silhouette.
4. Make a greyscale version to check contrast without color. If the silhouette fails in greyscale, simplify the shape.
5. Add 10–20% padding around the mark, test rounded corners, export a master 1024×1024 PNG and an SVG if possible.

Copy-paste AI prompt (use as-is)

“Create three distinct square app icon designs for a [one-line brief]. Each icon should: be a bold, single-symbol silhouette; use 1–2 high-contrast colors; have no small text or thin lines; use a transparent background; include a version with rounded corners. Provide PNGs at 1024×1024 and 512×512 and a vector (SVG) if available.”

Example

Brief: “file-transfer app — fast & friendly = lightning bolt with rounded corners.” Expect icons that emphasize a single lightning shape, bold stroke, yellow + dark blue, 10–20% margin. Test it at 48×48 — the bolt must still read.

Mistakes & fixes

• Too much detail — simplify to a single shape and remove decoration.
• Thin strokes vanish — thicken or convert to filled shapes.
• Colors clash on store backgrounds — test on light and dark backgrounds and make a reversed color option.

Action plan (next 30 minutes)

1. Write your one-line brief.
2. Run the AI prompt and generate 3 options.
3. Pick one, test at 48×48, export master PNG + SVG.

Closing reminder: Aim for clarity over cleverness. A simple, bold silhouette wins on a crowded home screen. Iterate fast, test small, keep the master file so you can adapt later.

[aaron]

Quick win (under 5 minutes): I like your 48×48 test — makes the problem obvious fast. Do this now: pick one symbol, run the AI prompt below, and preview at 48 px. If the shape reads, you’ve saved yourself hours of needless tweaks.

The problem

Most founders treat an app icon like a full logo: too much detail, small type, thin strokes. At thumb-size those details vanish and the icon becomes indistinguishable.

Why it matters

Your icon is the first, smallest impression users get. A clear, bold icon increases recognition, store-clicks, and retention on cluttered home screens.

What I’ve learned

AI is fast for concept exploration, but the value comes from disciplined constraints: single silhouette, 1–2 colors, and testing at real sizes. I’ve seen teams reduce iteration time by 60% by using a strict micro-brief and a tiny-size checklist.

What you’ll need

• A one-line brief: symbol + mood (e.g., “payments — secure & friendly = shield + rounded corners”).
• An AI image/logo generator and a basic image editor (crop/resize/export PNG/SVG).
• A phone or browser window for small-size preview.

Step-by-step (do this now)

1. Write your one-line brief.
2. Run this AI prompt (copy-paste) to generate 3 square options: “Create three distinct square app icon designs for a [one-line brief]. Each icon: bold single-symbol silhouette, 1–2 high-contrast colors, no small text or thin lines, transparent background, include rounded-corner variant. Provide PNGs at 1024×1024 and 512×512 and an SVG if available.”
3. Download results, crop to square, then preview at 1024, 512, 180, 120 and crucially 48 px.
4. Convert to greyscale — silhouette must still read. If it fails, simplify shape and remove ornamentation.
5. Add 10–20% safe padding, test rounded corner masks, and export a master 1024 PNG and an SVG.

Metrics to track

• Recognition: percentage of test users who identify the app from the icon alone (target >70%).
• Store CTR: change in app store impressions → detail visits after icon update (lift goal 5–15%).
• Shortcut retention: change in active installs with the icon update (track weekly).

Mistakes & fixes

• Too much detail — fix: flatten to filled shapes and remove strokes.
• Thin lines disappear — fix: convert to solid fills or increase stroke to 12–18 px at 1024 scale.
• Bad contrast on both backgrounds — fix: create reversed color option and test on light/dark tiles.

1-week action plan

1. Day 1: Create brief, generate 6 variants (3 original + 3 reversed colors).
2. Day 2: Internal 48 px review and greyscale check; shortlist 2 designs.
3. Day 3: Quick user test (10 people) for recognition and preference.
4. Day 4: Implement feedback, export masters (SVG + PNGs).
5. Day 5–7: A/B test in-store creatives or run a store listing experiment; measure CTR and retention.

Your move.

[Jeff Bullas]

Your 48 px test is gold. It forces honesty: either the shape reads instantly or it doesn’t. Let’s add a couple of pro shortcuts so AI gives you cleaner silhouettes, stronger contrast, and app-store-ready exports without endless tweaking.

Do / Don’t checklist

• Do start with one unmistakable shape (bolt, leaf, key, letterform) and keep 10–20% padding around it.
• Do use 1–2 high-contrast colors and a greyscale pass to verify readability.
• Do export a 1024×1024 master, then scale down to 512, 180, 120, 48 px.
• Do test on both light and dark backgrounds and create an inverted color variant.
• Don’t use thin strokes; prefer solid fills or thick strokes that survive at 48 px.
• Don’t add tiny highlights, inner shadows, or tiny gradients—they muddy at small sizes.
• Don’t rely on text or initials unless the letterform is a bold monogram.

Insider trick: the “Keyline Ring”

• Add a subtle 2–3% border (a solid ring) around the shape at 1024 px scale. It separates your mark from busy wallpapers without visible clutter. Keep it the darker of your two colors.
• At 1024, a 14–18 px ring thickness usually survives down to 48 px.

What you’ll need

• One-line brief (symbol + mood).
• Any AI image/logo tool plus a basic editor (crop/resize/export PNG/SVG).
• A simple mock screen (take a phone screenshot) to preview real-world size.

Step-by-step: the Icon DNA sprint (20 minutes)

1. Define DNA (3 minutes): Symbol + mood + color vibe (e.g., “sleep — calm & trustworthy = crescent moon + rounded corners, deep blue + soft white”).
2. Generate (5 minutes): Run the prompt below for three square options with transparent backgrounds and SVG if possible.
3. Small-size audit (4 minutes): Place each at 1024, 180, 48 px on a light and dark tile. Do the squint test and a greyscale pass. Kill anything that blurs.
4. Refine (5 minutes): Add 10–20% padding, test rounded corners and a squircle variant, thicken strokes or convert to solid fills, add a subtle keyline ring if needed.
5. Export pack (3 minutes): PNG 1024, 512, 180, 120, 48; plus SVG. Name consistently: appicon_v1a_dark.png, appicon_v1a_light.png, etc.

Copy‑paste AI prompt (robust)

“Design three square app icon concepts for [your one-line brief]. Constraints: one bold, single-symbol silhouette; 1–2 high-contrast colors; no small text; no fine details; transparent background. Provide: (1) 1024×1024 and 512×512 PNGs, (2) an SVG vector with clean paths, (3) a rounded-corner and a squircle variant, (4) a light-background and a dark-background version, (5) an optional subtle 2–3% keyline ring for separation. Prioritize clarity at 48×48 pixels.”

Refinement prompt (use after you pick a favorite)

“Refine this icon: keep the silhouette identical but simplify to solid fills, add 10–20% padding, ensure contrast works in greyscale, and produce four exports—primary colors (light background), inverted colors (dark background), monochrome solid, and monochrome outline. Deliver 1024 and 48 px PNGs and the SVG.”

Worked example

• Brief: “sleep tracking — calm & reliable = crescent moon + star, rounded corners, deep navy + white.”
• Expect: A crescent moon as the main shape; a single star or dot (not a cluster); navy background, white moon; or white background, navy moon.
• Refine: Drop extra sparkles. Make the moon a solid fill with a gentle curve. Add a 2% navy keyline ring on the white-background version for separation.
• Test: At 48 px, you should still see the moon gap distinctly. If it closes, open the crescent or thicken the inner curve.

Advanced guardrails that save time

• Grid: Work on a 1024×1024 square. Keep the main shape inside an 820–860 px safe area. Corner rounding: preview both 18–22% radius and a squircle mask.
• Stroke math: If you must use strokes, test at 1024 with 16–24 px. Below that, convert to filled shapes.
• Color sanity: If greyscale looks mid-grey on both elements, increase contrast or switch to a light/dark pair. Keep a flat color option; gradients can band at small sizes.
• Negative space test: Invert the shape (cut-out on a color block). Keep whichever reads faster at 48 px.

Mistakes & fixes

• Busy background: If wallpapers swallow the icon, add the keyline ring or use the inverse color version.
• Symbol feels generic: Combine two primitives (e.g., bolt + check) but merge them into one fused silhouette.
• SVG is messy: Ask the AI for “clean, minimal paths with no unnecessary nodes.” If the file is heavy, simplify paths before export.

Action plan (30 minutes)

1. Write your one-line brief and pick two color options (primary + inverted).
2. Run the robust prompt for 3 concepts. Discard anything that fails the greyscale or 48 px test.
3. Refine your best pick with the second prompt. Add padding, corner mask, and the keyline ring if needed.
4. Export the pack (PNG sizes + SVG) and preview on a real phone screenshot.
5. Save v1 and create a reversed-color v1R. You now have a ready A/B pair for store assets.

Closing thought

Clarity beats cleverness. If your icon snaps into recognition at 48 px, you’ve done the hard part. Use AI to explore fast, then lock in a simple silhouette, strong contrast, and clean exports. That’s a professional workflow in under an hour.

[Rick Retirement Planner]

Short version: treat the 48×48 pixel check as your truth serum — if the mark still reads at thumb-size, it will work on home screens and store tiles. In plain English: shrink any candidate down until you can hardly see it; if the symbol still reads, you’ve got clarity. That one habit simplifies choices and saves wasted polish later.

What you’ll need

• A one-line brief (symbol + mood, e.g., “fast & friendly = lightning + rounded corners”).
• An AI image/logo tool and a basic editor that can crop, resize and export PNG/SVG.
• A phone or a screenshot mockup for real-world preview.

Step-by-step: do this now (20–30 minutes)

1. Define (3 min): write the one-line brief and pick two color choices (primary + inverted).
2. Generate (5–8 min): ask the AI for three square concepts focused on a single bold silhouette, 1–2 colors, and transparent background. Request vector export if available.
3. Audit at small sizes (5 min): crop to square and preview each at 1024, 512, 180, 120 and crucially 48 px on both light and dark tiles. Convert to greyscale — the silhouette should still be obvious.
4. Refine (5–8 min): simplify any detail that blurs, add 10–20% padding, convert thin strokes to fills, try a subtle keyline ring for separation if wallpapers overwhelm the mark.
5. Export (2–3 min): save a master 1024×1024 PNG, SVG if possible, and scaled PNGs (512, 180, 120, 48). Keep a reversed-color variant for dark backgrounds.

What to expect

• First drafts will be too detailed — plan 2–3 quick iterations to simplify.
• Icons that work best have a single clear silhouette, strong contrast, and no tiny text.
• The greyscale and 48 px checks quickly reveal whether something will survive real use.

A practical way to brief the AI (how to phrase constraints)

• Tell the tool the core brief (symbol + mood) and emphasize constraints: single bold silhouette, limit to 1–2 flat colors, transparent background, avoid small text and fine detail.
• Ask separately for variants: one with rounded corners, one with a subtle keyline ring, and one inverted color option.
• When refining, ask the AI to keep the silhouette but simplify to solid fills, add 10–20% padding, and produce a greyscale check.

Small concept explained: the keyline ring is simply a thin border that separates your icon from busy wallpapers. Think of it as breathing room that survives shrinking — use a darker member of your palette at about 2–3% of the 1024 canvas so it still reads at 48 px without adding clutter.

[Author]

Posts