The Big Mistake Most Bloggers Make and 5 Tips on How to Fix It

The Big Mistake Most Bloggers Make and 5 Tips on How to Fix it

There are two key aspects when it comes to online marketing: First, your marketing should drive traffic to your blog or website and second, it should convert that traffic into customers.

Almost 95% of business sites fail to achieve traffic conversion. That is the big mistake most bloggers make.

As a business owner and blogger, you want to make sure the money spent in creating your website is worth it. After all, what’s the point of driving thousands of unique visitors to your blog but not convert one?

The problem may not be your service/product but the “call-to-action” or CTA you’re using (you are using CTAs, aren’t you?)

A CTA is a hyperlinked image or text that urges the visitor to do something. Common examples of CTA are “Click here”, “Download now” and “Subscribe” buttons.


CTAs such as above are a hit or miss because, well, they are too generic. Instead, it’s a much better idea to create a CTA that is specific to your product or service to get more leads and clicks.

Before we look at how to create high-conversion buttons, here are the some types you can use on your website and blog.

4 types of “call to action”

Here are some of the major types of calls to action that are used for websites and blogs

1. Add to Cart or Buy Now: Generally used by e-commerce sites to promote and nudge you to buy their products.

2. Free trial: These buttons let a user trial your service for free for a few days and reduces anxiety attached to a purchase. During the free trial period, users receive tutorials, tips and hacks on how to make the most of their trial, with a gentle reminder of the number of days left before trial period expires.

3. Sign up: Used for signing up to a service, a newsletter or a monthly online program.

4. Download: Serve the same purpose as “Buy now” buttons, or they may be used to invite a visitor to download a freebie. I find download buttons are more enticing than their “Add to cart” counter-parts.

There could be variations of the above, but you can apply the following 5 steps to any type of CTA.

Here are 5 steps to improve your Call-to-Action

#1. Make them stand out

Most websites just include a CTA button such as “Add to cart” without the image of the product. Once you include an image of your product, they know what they are getting when they click the button. It might work for you or it might not, but it clearly is worth trying.

Another tip is to make your buttons stand out from the rest of your page. SAP tested a large, orange colored button on their page. This is how the control and test pages looked.

Control page

Call to Action Tips for Bloggers

Test page

Call to Action Tips for Bloggers

With the inclusion of big, orange button, their conversion rates increased by 32.5%.

Don’t be afraid to make your CTA stand out — experiment and test what works best for your brand.

#2. Use active verbs

If you do what others are doing, you may be disappointed. If doing X makes someone else’s conversion rates touch the sky, why can’t you do the same and expect the same results?

Simply because your brand is different and unique than anyone else’s. Rather than copying someone, make your button copy relevant to what you’re offering.

Check out how CrazyEgg uses a specific CTA “Show me my heat map” instead of a generic “Click here”.

Call to Action Tips for Bloggers

As a rule-of-thumb, try using action verbs that nudge them to take positive action. For example, “Learn more”, “Get started” or “Yes, send me my free pack!”

#3. Use appropriate size

Although it’s good to have a catchy CTA button, a button too large will overpower your web page and not convert very well.

On the extreme end, a button too small and grey in color will get lost on your page.

You have to find a sweet spot where your button catches attention and stands out at the same time doesn’t stop your visitors from reading the rest of copy on the page if they wish.

Ideally, your CTA button should be the largest button on your page. It should not use overly contrasting colors so as to blend in with everything at the same time.

Keep running A/B tests no matter how “minor” the change and repeat what’s working for you.

Check out how HubSport uses two non-contradicting CTAs at the bottom of their blog posts – the one that’s specific to a post is larger in size (first preferred action); the other is more generic and smaller in size (second preferred action).

Call to Action Tips for Bloggers

#4. Optimize for SEO

Optimize your buttons and banners for SEO by including an appropriate alt tag with rich keywords. Most backends like WordPress allow you to create alt tags easily.

SEO will improve your visibility on search engines like Google and send more traffic your way.

#5. Get creative

Making small changes, like color or placement of your CTA can have huge effects. Kymberly Snyder did an A/B test of making people watch a 30-min long video with no option of skipping it. It was only after the video finished that a CTA button appeared.

This sounds against logic because you think people will leave the page out of frustration. Instead, it actually led to 144% increase in conversions of pre-qualified leads.

Another common tip is to include your CTAs “above the fold” – this means your visitor doesn’t have to scroll down the page in order to notice a CTA. By all means, go ahead and include it above the fold, but don’t assume this will lead to an increase in your conversion numbers.

Why? Because it’s is about what you say and how you say it more than it is about position. Sometimes, your prospects are better motivated to do something once they have read through the copy.

Others already want to buy from you – they are pre-qualified and ready to buy, so they might as well be given a CTA above the fold without much of reading any copy. This post explores 3 key scenarios you should evaluate before going above or below the folds.

For better results, you can use banners combined with buttons as CTAs like QuickSprout does here:

Call to Action Tips for Bloggers

By the way, you don’t have to spend a fortune on CTA banners. There are tons of free tools that let you do it online; one good example is Visme.

Without a stellar call-to-action, your visitors will get confused or worse, they will leave your page. Make sure you utilize your CTA so they keep moving in the direction you want them to.

Guest author: Payman Taei is the founder of HindSite Interactive, an award winning web design and development company that creates custom web and mobile sites and applications for businesses and organizations.


Want to start your blog today?

Want to start a WordPress blog in 5 minutes? The blog is hosted by Bluehost Web Hosting. For only $3.95 a month, Bluehost can help you set up and host your website/blog quickly and easily. Because is a Bluehost affiliate partner, my readers can visit this page to receive a 50% discount off the monthly price and a free domain name. 


  • drericagoodstone

    These are really valuable pointers about how to increase our optins. Thank you for sharing your insights.
    Dr. Erica

    • Payman Taei

      Dr. Erica; glad the article could give you some insight to better your conversions.

  • Philippe

    I am a beginner and I see your CTAs in your post but, what about buttons? Note of interest in your specific case?

  • Philippe

    Very nice post and attractive CTA but what about buttons? Did you perform AB tests?
    Thank you.

    • Payman Taei

      Philippe, thank you. To answer your question; the buttons are often the CTA. Have been involved in multiple A/B tests in the past; it definitely is a necessity to gear towards the maximum conversion.

      If there is one thing I’ve learned in testing is, never assume you know better than your audience. You can assume you know what will convert best, but at end of day AB tests can give you the benefit of the doubt of which version (even if it’s a change in button color) converts best.

  • Sherman Smith

    Hey Jeff,

    I found this blog through a facebook friend of mine and I love the value that you presented here. I haven’t realize how many different types of CTA’s you can utilize on your blog, but I’m glad that you mentioned there isn’t just one way of doing it. I definitely want to be more creative and figure a more novelty, unprecedented and attractive way of doing this. Thanks for sharing!

    • Payman Taei

      hey Sherman. Glad you found the article useful. There are best practices but I find that the type of CTA (be it the message, style or size of button) is greatly influenced by the page and content it is presented on. As some of the examples showed, there is no single cookie cutter style.

  • Barbara Mckinney

    I cannot agree with you more,Payman.A major part of writing a blog post is to generate a response and this becomes more difficult when a call to action is absent from your post. You need to incent your readers to take action and this is exactly what a call to action will help you do. The reason you write is to get readers to take action in some way, shape or form.

    • Payman Taei

      Thanks Barbara. You’re right; at end of day the content is meant to deliver an action and have a purpose and the Call to Action is the trigger.

  • FreddieFulton

    Great post Jeff and Payman Taei. I’ll be sharing this one. Thanks.

    One thing I would add is the CTA needs to follow through with its promise. Meaning you need to provide what you say you are going to provide with the Call to Action or you risk the penalty of the customer quickly hitting the “x” close button. Misrepresenting the benefits of clicking on the CTA is a recipe for disaster and upset visitors. My two cents.
    Thanks again

    • Payman Taei

      hey Freddie. Welcome.
      You’re absolutely right. It is all connected, from driving the right visitor to the page, to presenting the right message (which can also support what is to come after the CTA event) to the post click. My concentration on article in this case was mostly on the CTA itself.

  • Elizabeth Delaney

    Thanks for all these tips Jeff. Much appreciated…

  • RollTideWarEagle

    The CTA on our college football blog is below the fold. Will change that. Great tips. The hashtags on the numbers are cute. Thanks Y’all

  • Mary Norton

    That Bluehost offer is compelling. Do you have to pay extra for the “click and drag platform”?